Trump and Taiwan: A Burden on the U.S. or a Strategic Ally?

The ongoing rivalry between the U.S. and China has amplified Taiwan's strategic importance.

Donald Trump's evolving views on Taiwan suggest potential shifts in U.S. support. The question remains: Does Taiwan represent a significant burden for the U.S. or a valuable strategic partner? This analysis explores the intricate dynamics between Trump, Taiwan, and their implications for U.S.-China relations.

Key Takeaways

• Trump's transactional worldview and focus on China as the primary threat could shift U.S. foreign policy priorities towards Asia.
• Arms sales to Taiwan increased significantly under the Trump administration from $14 billion under Obama to $18 billion in just four years¹.
• Trump suggested that Taiwan should raise its defense budget to 10% of GDP, three times the current U.S. rate¹.
• Taiwan's current defense budget is at 2.45% of its GDP, and experts propose increasing it to 5-10% of GDP¹.
• Trump's stance on Taiwan's defense contributions and the economic impact of U.S. involvement reflects his transactional approach to foreign policy.

Understanding Trump's Shifting Stance on Taiwan Relations

Donald Trump's approach to Taiwan has been marked by both bold gestures and pragmatic shifts. Post-2016, he broke protocol by congratulating Taiwan's President Tsai Ing-wen, challenging the one-China policy². Despite this, his administration's actions, such as increased arms sales and high-level visits, have strengthened U.S.-Taiwan ties³.

Trump's Transactional View of Taiwan Defense

Trump views Taiwan's defense through a transactional lens. He urged Taiwan to boost its military spending to 10% of its GDP, mirroring his broader stance on allies' defense investments³. This has sparked concerns about Taiwan's security implications.

Evolution of Trump's Taiwan Policy

Trump's Taiwan policy has evolved, moving from questioning the one-China policy to supporting it without conditions³. This change reflects both pragmatic considerations and the influence of his advisors, who favor a traditional approach to cross-strait relations.

Recently, Trump hinted at reducing support for Taiwan if re-elected, stressing the need for self-reliance³. This suggests ongoing fluidity in his stance, casting doubt on the future of U.S.-Taiwan relations.

"The U.S. and its allies are expected to implement a more 'robust deterrent' strategy in the Taiwan Strait as suggested by the America First Policy Institute (AFPI), related to Trump's policies."

³

The evolving global landscape necessitates a deep understanding of Trump's Taiwan policy. This knowledge is crucial for navigating the intricate cross-strait tensions and the U.S. foreign policy challenges that lie ahead²³.

Military Aid and Arms Sales Under Trump Administration

The Trump administration demonstrated a robust commitment to enhancing Taiwan's military prowess. They significantly increased arms sales and defense cooperation⁴. Trump advocated for Taiwan to allocate 10% of its GDP to defense, a figure three times the U.S. rate. This underscores Taiwan's strategic importance within the U.S.-dominated "first island chain" in the Pacific⁴.

Under Trump, arms sales to Taiwan surged to $18 billion in four years, surpassing the $14 billion over eight years of the previous administration⁴. The U.S. Taiwan Travel Act of 2018 facilitated higher-level exchanges, bolstering their military deterrence and strategic alliance⁴.

Elbridge Colby and Robert O'Brien suggested Taiwan increase its defense budget to 10% and 5% of its GDP, respectively. This would enhance its military deterrence capabilities⁴. Matthew Pottinger, Trump's former deputy national security adviser, urged Taiwan to prepare for a possible Chinese invasion. He emphasized the importance of Taiwan's defense preparedness within the U.S. foreign policy framework⁴.

With a possible second Trump administration, the focus on Asia, including countering China, is expected to persist. This will offer opportunities for Taiwan to augment its security through increased defense spending and U.S. weapons purchases⁴. Trump's transactional worldview may also lead to more active U.S. involvement in East Asia. This will fortify the strategic alliance between the U.S. and Taiwan⁴.

"The United States has sold Taiwan nearly $50 billion in defense equipment and services"⁵.

As of August 2024, Taiwan awaits the delivery of over $20 billion in U.S. military equipment. In late 2022, Congress approved legislation allowing Taiwan to receive up to several billion dollars annually in U.S. military aid. Taiwan has acquired a range of U.S. military assets, including guided-missile destroyers, frigates, F-16 fighter jets, Abrams tanks, and Patriot missile defense systems. This acquisition significantly enhances its military deterrence capabilities⁵.

Trump Taiwan U.S.-Burden on the U.S Strategic Ally China and Taiwan

President Donald Trump's stance on Taiwan has been multifaceted, viewing it as both a strategic asset and a financial burden for the U.S⁶.. He advocated for Taiwan to boost its defense spending to 10% of its GDP, aiming to spread defense costs among allies⁶. This move underlines the economic and strategic implications of U.S. support for Taiwan, reflecting the Trump administration's strategic assessment.

Economic Implications of Support

Trump's transactional approach to Taiwan's defense has sparked debate over the U.S.'s long-term commitment to the island's security⁷. His aggressive trade policies against China, including proposed tariffs of up to 60%, could shave off up to two percentage points from China's GDP⁶. This could, in turn, affect Taiwan's economic stability and regional security.

Strategic Value Assessment

Taiwan's strategic importance in the U.S.-China rivalry remains significant, thanks to its semiconductor industry and geopolitical location⁷. Trump's "peace through strength" foreign policy⁷ aims to utilize Taiwan as a key player in maintaining regional stability and deterring China.

Defense Burden Distribution

The Trump administration's push for Taiwan to increase its defense spending is part of a broader effort to distribute defense costs among allies⁷. This strategy aims to reduce U.S. dependence on China for critical goods and enhance Taiwan's military readiness⁷. It could potentially strengthen regional security over time.

The Biden administration faces the challenge of managing the complex U.S.-Taiwan-China relationship. The economic implications, strategic value, and defense burden distribution will be critical in shaping future policies².

"Trump's assertive tactics could exploit China's vulnerabilities, such as a stagnating economy, and transform the rivalry in America's favor."⁶

The Trump administration's approach to Taiwan underscores the imperative for a nuanced equilibrium between economic interests, strategic objectives, and the distribution of burdens among allies. As the U.S. navigates this intricate relationship, the implications for regional stability and military deterrence will be under intense scrutiny.

Taiwan's Military Preparedness and Defense Capabilities

Taiwan's military confronts formidable challenges in deterring a Chinese invasion. Critics emphasize the need for improved planning, enhanced stockpiles, and more effective training⁸. China has significantly expanded its missile arsenal, now boasting hundreds of mobile launchers with over 1,000 medium-range and 500 intermediate-range ballistic missiles⁸. The PLA commands the world's largest navy and is developing advanced fighter jets and bombers⁸. China's Chang Guang Satellite Technology Company has over 100 satellites in orbit, aiming to triple that by 2025⁸. Taiwan's military budget remained flat from 2000 to 2018, while China's forces grew significantly⁸.

Reforms are urgently needed to bolster Taiwan's defensive capabilities. This includes investing in asymmetric warfare tactics and technologies⁹. Some advocate for a "porcupine strategy" to make invasion costly for China⁹. The Task Force on US-Taiwan Relations, led by Ambassador Robert C. O'Brien (ret.), has collaborated with Taiwanese officials and experts to assess the island's military readiness⁹.

Taiwan's strategic location and the impact of a Chinese invasion on regional security and the global economy underscore the criticality of its military capabilities. This is a pivotal factor in U.S.-China relations and the broader strategic alliance in the Indo-Pacific.¹⁰

Strategic Importance of Taiwan in U.S.-China Relations

Taiwan's significance in the U.S.-China dynamic transcends its semiconductor industry's influence on the global technological landscape¹¹. Its strategic positioning within the "first island chain" off China's coast is pivotal for maintaining regional security and stability¹². This location underpins the U.S. Indo-Pacific strategy, facilitating the projection of American influence and countering China's expansion in the region¹².

Semiconductor Industry Impact

The semiconductor industry in Taiwan is integral to the global technological framework¹¹. As China's technological prowess advances, Taiwan's dominance catalyzes a geopolitical rivalry with the U.S¹².. The loss of this industry to China would have profound economic repercussions for the U.S. and its allies¹¹.

Regional Security Balance

Taiwan's location within the "first island chain" is crucial for regional security¹². Its proximity to China and control over critical sea lanes render it a strategic asset for the U.S¹².. Ensuring Taiwan's security and democracy is imperative for U.S. regional stability¹².

First Island Chain Strategy

The "first island chain" is pivotal in U.S. strategy within the Indo-Pacific¹². A robust presence in this chain, encompassing Taiwan, is imperative to curtail China's expansive influence¹². Taiwan's pivotal role in this strategy is essential for the U.S. to counterbalance China's ascendancy and uphold its dominance¹².

Taiwan's strategic importance in U.S.-China relations is multifaceted, ranging from its technological prowess to its geopolitical significance¹¹. These dimensions underscore Taiwan's critical role in U.S. foreign policy, aiming for a stable, prosperous, and democratic Indo-Pacific¹².

Trump's "America First" Policy Impact on Taiwan

Donald Trump's "America First" policy has profoundly impacted Taiwan's relationship with the U.S¹³. This policy advocates for a more equitable distribution of burdens among allies, potentially elevating Taiwan's defense expenditures. It also endeavors to counterbalance China's burgeoning influence in the region¹⁴. This stance has precipitated increased U.S. engagement in Asia, which could strategically benefit Taiwan¹⁴.

Conversely, Trump's transactional perspective on international relations has raised doubts regarding the U.S. commitment to Taiwan's security¹⁴. The prospect of reinstated tariffs under Trump could jeopardize Taiwan's economy, which is intricately linked to Chinese supply chains¹⁴. Such a scenario could catalyze economic decoupling, prompting U.S. companies to relocate their supply chains away from China, impacting Taiwan and other Asian economies¹⁴.

The intensifying U.S.-China tech rivalry under Trump threatens global tech cooperation and supply chains¹⁴. Semiconductors and AI are at risk, potentially driving China towards technological self-sufficiency. This could escalate military tensions and destabilize the region, including Taiwan's security¹⁴.

As the U.S. and its allies, such as Japan and South Korea, confront these challenges, Taiwan may need to forge new strategic alliances¹⁴. The Trump administration's emphasis on defense autonomy and leadership in the Indo-Pacific may lead to increased military aid and arms sales. This could complicate cooperation with organizations like ASEAN¹⁴.

Trump's "America First" policy has introduced both opportunities and uncertainties for Taiwan¹³. The island nation must navigate a complex geopolitical landscape and adapt its alliances to ensure its security and economic prosperity¹³.

Cross-Strait Tensions and U.S. Strategic Ambiguity

The relationship between China and Taiwan is a complex geopolitical challenge. The United States must navigate a fine line of strategic ambiguity¹⁵. This balance has become more strained with China's military assertiveness and Taiwan's growing self-confidence, escalating cross-strait tensions¹⁵.

Historical Context

For over four decades, the U.S. has followed a policy of "strategic ambiguity" on defending Taiwan against a Chinese attack¹⁶. This stance has helped manage the sensitive issue diplomatically. Yet, it's now under scrutiny by some American scholars and officials¹⁶.

Current Diplomatic Challenges

China's military growth and Taiwan's push for autonomy have complicated the U.S. position¹⁵. The U.S. must deter Chinese aggression without provoking it. It must also maintain strong economic ties with both sides¹⁶.

"The military balance across the Taiwan Strait has been deteriorating over time, urging a reconsideration of U.S. policies towards Taiwan."¹⁶

The United States must navigate the complex landscape of china-taiwan relations and address cross-strait tensions while maintaining strategic ambiguity¹⁵¹⁶.

Economic Interdependence Between Taiwan and the U.S.

The economic ties between Taiwan and the United States are profound, centered around the technology sector. Taiwan's semiconductor industry is instrumental for U.S. tech behemoths, producing over 60% of global semiconductors¹⁷. This interdependence complicates the economic and strategic dynamics in U.S.-Taiwan relations.

Former President Trump has questioned this relationship, stating Taiwan took almost 100% of U.S. chip industry. Yet, the reality is more complex¹⁸. Taiwan's semiconductor dominance makes it a key economic and geopolitical ally for the U.S. Both nations aim to manage the economic implications and strategic alliance amidst their geopolitical rivalry with China.

The Biden Administration's 2022 National Security Strategy emphasizes the U.S. commitment to peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait. It acknowledges Taiwan's critical role in the U.S.-China competition for regional dominance¹⁷. This highlights the significance of Taiwan-U.S. economic and technological ties. These ties will influence the future of their strategic alliance and geopolitical rivalry in the Indo-Pacific.

"Taiwan is central to the U.S.–China competition for regional leadership, which is deemed by U.S. officials as 'America's most consequential geopolitical challenge.'"

The Role of Taiwan in U.S. Indo-Pacific Strategy

Taiwan has become a vital component in the U.S. Indo-Pacific strategy, acting as a democratic ally and strategic partner. The region's growing significance is evident in the increased focus on Taiwan in recent National Security Strategies (NSS) and defense reports¹⁹. The Biden administration's Indo-Pacific strategy has elevated Taiwan's status to that of a "leading regional partner," alongside other key nations like India, Indonesia, and Vietnam¹⁹.

Military Cooperation

The military cooperation between the U.S. and Taiwan has grown, with the U.S. supplying advanced weaponry and training. This aid enhances Taiwan's defensive capabilities, contributing to regional stability¹⁹. The Pentagon's Indo-Pacific strategy report identifies Taiwan as a "reliable, capable, and natural partner" of the United States. The goal is to ensure Taiwan's security and its ability to engage with mainland China on its own terms¹⁹.

Democratic Alliance Building

Taiwan's democracy aligns with the U.S. efforts to form a coalition of democratic nations in the Indo-Pacific region to counter China's growing influence¹⁹. The Department of State's Indo-Pacific strategy report in 2019 highlighted Taiwan in areas such as bilateral partnerships, digital economy, and good governance¹⁹. This strategic partnership is essential for promoting democratic values and maintaining regional stability.

Yet, the Trump administration's approach to Taiwan may have emphasized military aspects over democratic values in its strategic considerations¹⁹. The U.S. faces the challenge of balancing its commitment to Taiwan's security with its dedication to democratic principles, which are central to its Indo-Pacific strategy.

"Supporting Taiwan is in the U.S.' strategic interest," as mentioned by Randall Schriver, former Assistant Secretary of Defense for Indo-Pacific Affairs under President Trump¹⁹.

The U.S. has expressed a steadfast commitment to maintaining peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait, recognizing its critical role for regional and global security¹⁹. The Indo-Pacific region is responsible for two-thirds of global growth in gross domestic product (GDP) and accounts for 60 percent of global GDP²⁰. Ensuring stability in this economically vital region is a primary strategic priority for the United States.

Trump's Second Term: Implications for Taiwan

A second term for former President Donald Trump could significantly alter U.S.-Taiwan relations. Trump's recent comments hint at a more transactional stance on Taiwan's defense. This might lead to reduced U.S. support unless Taiwan boosts its defense spending²¹. Yet, Taiwan's strategic value in countering China could limit drastic policy changes².

The selection of advisors like J.D. Vance, who champions prioritizing China, could sway policy directions²¹. If Republicans control both the House and Senate, they can pass significant legislation more easily²¹. This might include lowering corporate tax rates and tweaking the income tax system²¹.

Trump's second term could also usher in a renewed deregulation push, mainly in energy and environmental areas²². This might involve undoing Biden's vehicle emissions rules and boosting domestic oil output²². Yet, the administration's stance on climate change and its effects on Taiwan's strategic role are unclear.

The implications of a Trump second term for Taiwan are complex and far-reaching. While Trump's transactional approach might strain U.S. support, Taiwan's strategic importance could moderate significant policy shifts². The makeup of Trump's foreign policy team and the congressional power dynamics will be key in shaping U.S.-Taiwan ties²¹²²².

Alternative Defense Strategies and Burden Sharing

The U.S. military's edge is waning, facing challenges in engaging in and winning multiple major conflicts at once¹⁰. Taiwan must now explore new defense strategies to boost its military deterrence and strengthen its alliance with the U.S. These include developing asymmetric warfare capabilities, investing in robust cyber defense systems, and establishing a territorial defense force¹⁰. These efforts aim to make a Chinese invasion of Taiwan costly and unappealing, reducing reliance on traditional military hardware.

Burden-sharing discussions are also vital, as the U.S. pushes its allies and partners to contribute more to defense against threats from Russia, Iran, and North Korea¹⁰. This includes Taiwan, where increased defense spending and contributions from regional allies like Japan and South Korea are essential for regional stability and military deterrence¹⁰. These efforts align with the Trump administration's push for allies to take more responsibility for their defense, given China's rising economic and military power²³.

Defense strategy prioritization is critical, given the U.S. military's constraints and the threat of multiple major conflicts¹⁰. By adopting alternative defense strategies and strengthening regional burden-sharing, Taiwan can enhance its military deterrence, its alliance with the U.S., and contribute to regional stability against China's growing ambitions¹⁰²³.

Source Links

1. What a Trump re-election would mean for Taiwan
2. How is Trump’s reelection likely to affect US foreign policy?
3. The Prospect Foundation－Prospects & Perspectives－Prospects for Foreign Policy and Taiwan-U.S. Relations under the Second Trump Administration
4. What a Trump Re-election Would Mean for Taiwan
5. U.S. Military Support for Taiwan in Five Charts
6. Opinion | Donald Trump Changed the Game With China. Now He Could Win It.
7. What Trump’s Win Means for U.S. Foreign Policy
8. The Taiwan Fallacy
9. PDF
10. The Prioritization Imperative: A Strategy to Defend America’s Interests in a More Dangerous World
11. PDF
12. U.S.-China Relations for the 2030s: Toward a Realistic Scenario for Coexistence
13. Donald Trump's Foreign Policy Positions
14. America First, Again: How Trump’s Return Could Reshape U.S.-Asia Relations | Beyond the Horizon ISSG
15. The United States, China, and Taiwan: A Strategy to Prevent War
16. Should the United States change its policies toward Taiwan?
17. The American Case for Taiwan
18. US Strategic Ambiguity Over Taiwan Must End | by Abe Shinzō - Project Syndicate
19. U.S. evolving strategic thinking about Taiwan
20. PDF
21. Trump 2.0: Initial Roundup of Key Policy Issues and Expectations
22. A Look at the Upcoming Trump Administration's Policy Priorities | Insights | Holland & Knight
23. Trump II and US Nuclear Assurances in the Indo-Pacific